More Top Stories - Sponsored by FansKnowBest.com
Scouting Combine Day 3
...Day 3 of the NFL Scouting Combine examines the top collegiate linebackers and defensive linemen in this year’s draft. Pass-rushing defensive ends are always...
Scouting Combine Day 2
...The second day of the NFL Scouting Combine featured the workouts of the skill position players: quarterbacks, running backs, and wide receivers. Let’s take a closer look...
Scouting Combine Day 1
...The NFL Scouting Combine got underway in earnest on Saturday, February 22nd. The nation’s top college talent gathered in Indianapolis on...
2008 NFL Draft 1st Round Draft Grades
Jason Pughe
Updated May 1, 2008...
.
We provide our draft grades for the first round of the 2008 NFL Draft:
1st Round
1st Round |
|
|
Jake Long OT Michigan This move makes sense for the Dolphins. With Ronnie Brown coming back from injury and young QB’s in Beck and Henne, they need to protect them. Plus, Parcells knows what he is doing. Grade: A |
|
Chris Long DL Virginia Many thought this pick was either Chris Long or Glenn Dorsey. The Rams needed help on the offensive line but Jake Long was already gone. Long is more versatile than Dorsey, but might not have as much talent. Good pick, but offensive line was a bigger need. Grade: A- |
|
Matt Ryan QB Boston College While Atlanta needed a quarterback, I really feel they needed a superstar in Atlanta. I think McFadden is going to be a perennial pro bowler. This pick was to send a message that Ryan is the face of the franchise and he will stay out of trouble. Grade: B+ |
|
Darren McFadden RB Arkansas As I said before, McFadden in my opinion has the most upside in the draft. I think McFadden and Russell will provide a potent offense for years to come. Grade: A+ |
|
Glenn Dorsey DT LSU The Chiefs were extremely fortunate to have Dorsey fall to them at #5. Dorsey is a dominant defensive tackle that will help provide stability to the defensive line for years to come. Basically the Chiefs were able to fill two needs with first round talent in exchange for DE Jared Allen. Grade: A+ |
|
Vernon Gholston DE Ohio State Many draft experts are not big fans of Gholston. Gholston might not have been dominant at times during the games, but he has the size and speed to be dominant at the next level. The Jets need a DE like this for their 3-4 scheme, so it filled a need. Grade: B+ |
|
Sedrick Ellis DT USC The Saints moved up for this pick, so they obviously wanted Ellis. Personally, I felt like the Saints needed help at cornerback more, but if they can get to the quarterback it will make the cornerbacks jobs a lot easier. Ellis is a solid pick and will help out immediately. Grade: A- |
|
Derrick Harvey DE Florida The Jags made a stunning move and traded up to get Harvey. I think they could’ve picked up Harvey at #12 because Carolina could’ve possible grabbed him. The Jags needed big help at defensive end and Long and Gholston were off the board. Grade: A- |
|
Keith Rivers LB USC Rivers has the size and speed to be a dominant linebacker in the NFL. The only thing that worries me is that he wasn’t dominant at USC; he was just a solid player that got the job done. Every team needs that but at the #9 pick you are hoping for a superstar. Grade: B+ |
|
Jerod Mayo LB Tennessee As usual the Patriots make a surprising pick. The Patriots probably could’ve grabbed Mayo in the 20’s. I can’t really question the Patriots, but personally I think this was a little too high to pick Mayo. Grade: B |
|
Leodis McKelvin CB Troy McKelvin is probably the #1 cornerback in the draft and filled a need for the Bills. McKelvin was highly rated out of high school but grade concerns led to Troy being one of the few teams that took a chance on him. Grade: A |
|
Ryan Clady OT Boise State Out of all the offensive linemen in the draft, I think Clady has the most upside. The Broncos will continue their tradition of zone blocking and producing solid running backs. This move also protects franchise quarterback Jay Cutler. Grade: A |
|
Jonathan Stewart RB Oregon I really felt like Carolina had bigger needs at quarterback, and defensive end. I also feel like there were other running backs on the board that were better than Stewart. Stewart is often injured and they used a first round pick to have him share the backfield with DeAngelo Williams. Grade: B- |
|
Chris Williams OT Vanderbilt I think the Bears made a good move here despite needing a quarterback and a running back as well. Williams can help anchor an offensive line that will help protect Rex Grossman and open up more holes for Cedric Benson. Grade: A |
|
Branden Albert OL Virginia The Chiefs really secured their needs in the first round. Albert could’ve been taken earlier in the draft so the Chiefs were fortunate to get him at #15. If I could trade Jared Allen and get Glenn Dorsey and Branden Albert in return, that sounds like a good deal to me. Grade: A+ |
|
Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie CB Tennessee State DRC was an unknown until his Senior Bowl and NFL Combine performances. DRC has incredible speed and even though he played at Tennessee State, he’ll be a good one at the next level. The Cardinals already have the offense, so going defense was a good pick. Grade: A |
|
Gosder Cherilus OT Boston College I was hoping the Lions would have gone running back here. Mendenhall would have been a big pick up for them. While the Lions needed offensive line help, I’m not sure Cherilus was the right pick so early. Grade: B |
|
Joe Flacco QB Delaware It’s no secret that the Ravens love Flacco. He’s a big quarterback with a cannon for an arm, but I think Brian Brohm was a better prospect. Brohm is ready to come in and compete and has played in a pro style offense. Grade: B |
|
Jeff Otah OT Pittsburgh The Panthers must be dedicating this season to the run and protecting Jake Delhomme. With both of their two 1st round picks, they completely ignored their quarterback and defensive end needs. Grade: B- |
|
Aqib Talib CB Kansas Ronde Barber is getting older, so this was a solid replacement pick. The Bucs win with defense and taking Talib shows that commitment to the defensive side of the ball. Grade: A |
|
Sam Baker OT USC Why trade up for Baker? Were the Falcons scared that the OT’s were falling off the board? I think Baker could’ve been picked up later in the 1st, if not early in the 2nd. Grade: C |
|
Felix Jones RB Arkansas Everyone knew that if Jones was available here that the Cowboys would take him. He’s a perfect compliment to Marion Barber and has a chance to contribute on special teams as well. Grade: A |
|
Rashard Mendenhall RB Illinois Aside from McFadden, the best back in the draft in my opinion. I’m not sure the Steelers need him with Parker and I wish I could see Mendenhall get more PT on another team. I think the Steelers could’ve picked someone at a true need position here. Grade: B |
|
Chris Johnson RB East Carolina Johnson had the fastest 40 time at the combine and was very productive at East Carolina. This pick sends a message to LenDale White and the Titans have added some more explosiveness to go along with Vince Young. Grade: A- |
|
Mike Jenkins CB South Florida The Cowboys fulfilled their need at cornerback by grabbing Jenkins. Jenkins is a stud and could come in and start right away. The Cowboys had a great 1st round with Jones and Jenkins. Grade: A |
|
Duane Brown OT Virginia Tech Maybe this is why Atlanta moved up? Perhaps they knew that the Texans were going to grab Sam Baker. As with Atlanta’s pick, the Texas could’ve moved down even more to get Brown. Grade: B |
|
Antoine Cason CB Arizona The Chargers are going to have one of the best defensive backfields in the NFL. Cason is a solid cornerback and will have a productive NFL career. Grade: A |
|
Lawrence Jackson DE USC The defensive end from Southern Cal was productive in college but not a superstar. The Seahawks need help at defensive end and Jackson was the best available on the draft board. Grade: A- |
|
Kentwan Balmer DT North Carolina The 49ers continue to rebuild on defense and Balmer is a run stuffer that they need. Plus, Balmer will allow Rookie of the Year Patrick Willis to create more havoc. Grade: A |
|
Dustin Keller TE Purdue I know a lot of people didn’t agree with this pick but after seeing Keller on tape, he’s going to be a good one. The Jets have a young quarterback and they’ve locked up Coles. Keller will give them another target and hopefully kick start that offense. Grade: A |
31. New England Patriots
|
Pick Forfeited for violating league rules. |
| 32. New York Giants
|
Kenny Phillips S Miami (FL) This could end up being the steal of the draft for the Giants. Phillips didn’t have a great year last year but if he’s even close to what he was the year before that, then the Giants have found a pro bowler. Grade: A+ |
Check out what our friends at Fans Know Best produced with this impressive 2008 Draft guide. It’s in PDF format, so download away only at this link:
http://www.fansknowbest.com/FansKnowBest%202008%20NFL%20Draft%20Packet.pdf



























